A guide to critiquing a research paper

Use the questions below to stimulate your thinking for your own critical evaluation of each of the therapeutic approaches for Theory Critique Research Paper:

A guide to critiquing a research paper on clinical supervision - NCBI

Sample Research Paper Critique.
Photo provided by

Sample Research Paper Critique - wikiHow

Writing a critique paper takes a lot of time and effort. Often, students try to find shortcuts to complete the paper in time such as simply summarizing, paraphrasing or copying and pasting the text. Using these steps when critiquing an article will not earn you a decent grade. The assignment can be particularly tasking when the assigned text is complex. Even after reading it several times, you may still have no idea where to start in your analysis. You may also have little understanding of research designs, sampling methods, and data analysis techniques. The critique requires that you affirm or challenge the validity of these methods and still, demonstrate a high level of understanding of the content.

A guide to critiquing a research paper on clinical ..

This paper presents a critique of a qualitative research article titled: ‘Perceived support from healthcare practitioners among adults with type 2 diabetes’ (Oftedal et al, 2010) (appendix 1). To enable the critique of this article the Caldwell critiquing tool (2005) will be utilized. (Appendix 2)

Research Paper Presentation and Critique - Lehigh CSE
Photo provided by
The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how we can critique a qualitative research article according to the criteria as recommended by McMillan & Wergin (1998:pp.7-12). The sample article being examined is by Goh (1999), A cognitive perspective on language learners’ listening comprehension problems. Whilst it is not possible to reproduce the article here, it is suggested that the critique procedure itself is being exercised in order to demonstrate its usefulness to readers of qualitative research. The guiding questions operate as effective criteria to understanding the quality and benefits of any given qualitative research paper. In this paper, we have taken a previously published article on nurses' judgements in abortion care performing a systematic critique of the merits of this research using a recognised critiquing framework.CONTENT:
The critique SHOULD NOT be a summary of the paper. You mustaddress the following questions in your critique:
1. What is the significance of this work and the questions addressed in it?
2. What are thestrengths and weaknesses of the research approach?
3. How well are the interpretationsand conclusions made by the author(s) supported by the data presented? Are therealternative explanations?
4. How far can theresults be extrapolated? In other words, does the design of the research and/or supporting studies allow its applicability to a wide range of ecosystems, geographic areas and times? Why or why not?
5. How do theconclusions drawn by the author(s) of this paper compare andcontrast with what others have found?
6. What questions doyou have that you now wish to explore further? For instance, howis this relevant to management applications and/or researchquestions?This assignment will critique the research paper “Patients’ case – notes: look but don’t touch” written by Bebbington, Parkin, James, Chichester and Kubiak (2003) (Appendix 1) using Benton and Comack’s (2000) framework (Appendix 2). This was selected because of the publicity that surrounds hospital acquired infection (Barrett, 2005).

Free article critique papers, essays, and research papers.

This is a guide to help you write a top class critique paper that will definitely earn you top marks. By- a custom writing services provider offering online writing services. Find us on facebook or like us on twitter . You can also read more tips and guidelines on writing different research papers by visiting our blog page now.

What is the importance of critiquing a research paper? - Quora

Organization of your critique research paper is important as it helps to present evidence in a structured manner for easy reading and clarification. Such research papers may work to critique some form of work that was previously done by another writer or creator. A journal, theory, or book may be evaluated by the student and then they write down their thoughts about what they reviewed. In other words, the author’s argument may be challenged by the student.

Understanding and critiquing quantitative research papers.

When it comes to essay writing, not only does one need to have knowledge about the particular subject, but also have the right writing skills, which is not everyone’s cup of tea. With the pressure of all college, high school and university courses and due papers, acquiring essay writing service has become a need for every student. Definitely, education is essential and it is a path which is not filled with roses. Having that said, students of today have their minds plagued with thoughts like, how to write critique research papers, or from where can I find good paper writing services or who can help in writing a critique paper.